Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Robert Maddox: His Troubles Continue

 In previous posts, I discussed arrests of suspected Confederate sympathizers in Campbell County, Ky., in late 1861.

I followed that up with a deeper look into the case of one suspected southern supporter who was arrested again in 1862, Hubbard Helm.

This post does the same for Robert Maddox.

On July 1, 1862, the military once again arrested him on suspicion of aiding the rebellion and confined him the Newport Barracks for a day before transferring him to Louisville.

New Provost Marshal Henry C. Gassaway spent much of his term searching for and arresting suspected Confederate supporters, including Maddox, but what led to such suspicions?

 On July 3, Gassaway wrote to Brigadier General Jeremiah T. Boyle in Louisville, the recently appointed Military Governor of Kentucky. He reported that he was going to pick up four affidavits concerning Maddox (Unfortunately, none of them remain in either Gassaway or Maddox' file on fold3.com). 

These testimonies showed him that Maddox was “a man of means" who "has great influence with his money particularly in his neighborhood and uses it freely to effect (sic) his ends. He is a dangerous man to our Government and if he and Yelton are held for some time it will do much good in quelling outburst among the Rebels in this county.” (Jesse Yelton was another accused southern supporter under arrest.)

Maddox again remained imprisoned for months. On the 4th of August, 93 Kentucky political prisoners at Camp Chase, 27 (29% of the total) from Campbell County alone, signed a letter to Kentucky Governor Beriah Magoffin asking him to have the state legislature help them. They had been “brought here by the force of arms, against our will and consent, in violation of the laws of Kentucky and the laws of the United States.” Robert Maddox was one of the signatories. 

Furthermore, these men complained that they were “confined and restrained of our rights and liberty that we are justly entitled to,” and again vowed that they were “law-abiding citizens” and “had not violated laws” of either Kentucky or “our common country.”

Their government proved unwilling or unable to help, and nothing happened.

On October 23, Ohio governor David Tod wrote to commanders at Camp Chase, requesting Maddox’ parole so that he could seek medical treatment in Columbus. 

Maddox signed a Parole of Honor, on October 15, 1862. He pledged his honor to report to Columbus, Ohio for medical treatment and not to leave there without permission from either Governor Tod or the commander at Camp Chase. He promised to report to the governor at 10:00 every morning and neither commit hostile acts against the U.S. Government nor aid the Confederacy.

In ten days from October 15th, he would report in person to the commander of Camp Chase. 


He complied with these orders and on November 8 signed a Release form that listed him as 44 years old, standing 5 feet 11 inches tall, and featuring a light complexion, light hair, and blue eyes. His facial hair was also of light hue. 

He then returned to daily life. In February of 1863, he was chosen to be a delegate at a Democratic conference in Frankfort.

——

This was not the end of his trouble with Union military leaders. 

On August 7, 1865, statewide elections took place, but in Campbell County military interference in the voting was the dominant topic, eventually leading to the voting being voided and then redone in the following February.

On this election day, Maddox was traveling to Cincinnati with a wagon full of pears to sell. He stopped at the Cold Spring blacksmith shop, which happened to be close to the polling place, to have his horse shod. He may have attempted to vote at the same time, but even if not, Captain J.W. Read of the 53rd Ky. Infantry arrested him. 

A story described Maddox as a native Kentucky who had never cast a vote outside of his home state. He was a legally qualified voter at the Cold Spring precinct, at least per the law at the time. Even General Palmer's order (issued on July 26, 1865, it was the edict that began the controversy around the 1865 election) should have protected Maddox, per the author, but Read "abused him most famously" simply because Maddox had been a Democrat. [Cincinnati Enquirer March 15, 1866]

Read also sent troops to arrest John McHatton, who was a tenant of Maddox. The captain was serious about limiting who voted. 

Fortunately for Maddox and his tenant, one of Read's superior officers released them the same day, but trouble still followed Maddox. 

On Saturday August 12, Read, perhaps miffed at being overruled, traveled to Maddox' home, removed him his bed, where he was lying sick. He took him to a local church where Read apprehended another man (Charles Murnan, an old resident whose story seems to be quite fascinating. Perhaps its worth another research project, but his obituary claims he had shook Lafayette's hand back in 1824 and had helped set up the state's old Constitution. It also states he had voted Democratic in every election, certainly the information Read had gathered). Read had the two men transported to Covington, in neighboring Kenton County, ordering them not to leave Campbell County soon. 

At some point not recorded, the men were set free and returned home.

Maddox' initial release had come via an order General John M. Palmer, who announced: "in substance as follows: 'That abundant evidence having been produced that said Maddox used his influence in getting men to join the Federal army is hereby released and his bond annulled."

This seems unusual for a supporter of the Confederate case, and a local newspaper noted the same, reporting "A great many Union men hereabout are anxious to know who testified before General Palmer that Mr. Maddox ever induced anyone to the Federal army.” They asked the newspaper to pose that question, obviously in disbelief of the story. [Cincinnati Daily Commercial, 8-26-65]

More than two dozen Campbell County men had been indicted for their actions during the 1865 election, but Governor Thomas Bramlette had pardoned them before they even faced trial. Local politician R. Tarvin Baker, who had also benefitted from military assistance in the polling, had encouraged Branlette to take this action, but had forgotten about Read's actions toward Maddox and Murnan, so Read was put on trial for those incidents. Read was convicted and fined $2,000.

After all this trouble, Maddox' name appeared on a list of 19 Campbell County men who sued Gassaway and other officials, all seeking $50,000 for false imprisonment. The lawsuits, called the "Camp Chase cases" in one account, bounced around in the court system for years. The last known mention of the suits was in the Cincinnati Daily Enquirer of December 11, 1867, which noted that the case was continued again, in the United States District Court in Covington.

Maddox continued participating in local Democratic politics. In the summer of 1866, he attended a meeting to select the party's Congressional candidate in the summer of 1866. [Cincinnati Daily Enquirer, August 22, 1866]

In February 1866 he went to another political meeting, this one in his hometown of Cold Spring, where he had faced the election day troubles a few months previously.

Adversity continued to find him. In February 1866, he went to another political meeting, this one in his hometown of Cold Spring, where he had faced the election day issues just a few months previously.
The meeting must have been a contentious one. Maddox “received two severe blows over the head from a cane in the hands of TJ Shafer,” who was convicted in court and given a fine as his punishment. 

Maddox then sued his attacker and won a verdict for $1,000. [Cincinnati Daily Enquirer, November 4, 1867]

After all these issues during and right after the war, Robert Maddox disappears from the spotlight, his life no longer documented as much as in the years 1861 -1865. This obscurity likely made him more than a little bit happy and perhaps brought him some peace and quiet.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Hubbard Helm's Troubles Continue in 1862

Former Campbell County, Ky., sheriff Hubbard Helm was no stranger to being arrested, as a previous post, about late 1861 Campbell County discussed.

1862 only added to this familiarity.

On July 19 of the new year, Union authorities, led by Provosty Marshal Henry C. Gassaway, arrested Helm, the third time this had happened.  They initially placed him in the Newport Barracks for more than a week, then transferred him to Camp Chase, near Columbus, Ohio. He was but one of numerous Campbell Countians arrested during this summer. 

These political arrests sometimes seemed arbitrary, but Gassaway did not act without reason, at least in his mind. Two local men gave him sworn statements about Helm on July 29, both putting the suspect's loyalty in questionable light.

Joseph Mariana acknowledged that he knew Helm. He stated the time the news arrived here of our forces having taken Fort Donaldson. He was talking with some union men at Barlow's Corner. He appeared to be excited. He stated that the news about Fort Donaldson being taken was a damned lie and any man that took that up was a liar and a Son of a Bitch. When news came of the defeat of the Federal Troops, he seemed to be elated and gratified. His manner and conduct as I have frequently witnessed it showed that he was the enemy of the Government and that he desired the success of the Southern Confederacy.

The comment about the "defeat of the Federal Troops" may have referred to a false report about the battle that Helm and/or others had heard. For instance, the Cincinnati Enquirer of February 14, 1862, reported that some local men claimed that US Grant was surrounded and "in imminent danger of being captured, together with all his army." Helm, Mariana, and others may have heard this or similar rumors, not unheard of when people (like even still today) were so anxious for news that they were liable to believe anything they heard. Reports of Confederate success would not have been unusual at this stage of the war.

Another man, James Perry, was acquainted with Helm and gave similar testimony as Mariana. Perry asserted that he had heard H. Helm swear that he was a Rebel and that we had no government. He said the Constitution was gone and we have no Constitution. At the time of the news of Fort Donalson arrived he was quite excited and said any man that said Fort Donaldson was taken was a damned lying Son of a Bitch. He expressions were all against our government.

These accusations, and perhaps others, provided Gassaway reason enough to act.

At Camp Chase, Helm was among 93 Kentucky prisoners there - a startling 27 just from Campbell County - who signed an August 4 letter to Kentucky Governor Beriah Magoffin asking him to have the state legislature help them. They insisted: “We were brought here by the force of arms, against our will and consent, in violation of the laws of Kentucky and the laws of the United States.”

They had been “confined and restrained of our rights and liberty that we are justly entitled to,” and repeated that they were “law-abiding citizens” and “had not violated laws” of either Kentucky or “our common country.”

Magoffin proved unable to provide the assistance they needed. 

--

On October 8, Ohio Governor Tod sent a note to a Major (name illegible) at the camp:

"Sir You will parole H.D. Helm a prisoner at Camp Chase to this city for 40 days upon the usual terms and conditions on account of his health."

On that same day, Helm signed a "Parole of Honor” form as a political prisoner of war. He promised that he would immediately go to Columbus for medical care, "and will not leave there without special permit" from Tod or the commanding officer at the camp. He agreed to report to Governor Tod at 10:00 every morning until told otherwise.

Helm further swore that he would do no "act of hostility" and would not "furnish any aid nor information" to the Confederacy. He agreed to return to Camp Chase after ten days and acknowledged that this parole was "granted on account of ill health."

On October 25, still in 1862, the Cincinnati Daily Enquirer reported that a group of unnamed "active Union men" of Newport were working on a petition to have Helm released. At this point, "The paper has received many signatures."

Those efforts may have helped. On that same date, the state's Judge Advocate sent a telegram to the commandant of Camp Chase: "You will parole HD Helm to go to Campbell Co Ky and return to your custody again within forty days by order of Secy. of War"

Helm signed another parole document on the 26th, this one stating that he would, without delay, return to Campbell County and not leave there without special permission from Governor Tod or Camp Chase's commanding officer.

He again agreed not to do anything to hurt the Union cause or aid the Confederacy "and in Forty days from this date" would report in person to the commander of Camp Chase.

This parole was per an order from Secretary of War Edwin Stanton.

—

On April 10, 1863, Helm received his complete freedom. He vowed that, after his release from the prison camp, I will immediately report in person to the Federal Military Commandant at Newport, Ky., and will thereafter, during the present rebellion, do no act of hostility against the Government of the United States, nor furnish any aid or comfort to the Enemies thereof.

This allowed him the freedom to leave Newport without special permission. He also no longer needed to report to anyone once he had visited the military leader in Newport.

This release was following a War Department order. This form announced: "H.D. Helm of Newport, Campbell Co. Ky., a political prisoner, is hereby released from custody on his parole of honor as above."


Eighteen days after signing his parole, he sent a letter asking for an official copy of his parole form for his records. 

He made it through the rest of the war unscathed, but in 1864 his name appeared on a list of Campbell County men drafted into the Union military. Whether the irony of his name on that list generated any conversation is unknown, but, perhaps needless to say, he did not serve in the Union army. 

He had not forgotten the treatment he had received. He was one of 19 Campbell County men who sued Gassaway and other officials, all seeking $50,000 in damages for their false arrests.  These lawsuits, called the "Camp Chase cases" in one account, bounced around in the courts for years, with the last mention I've found so far in the December 11, 1867, Cincinnati Enquirer, which state the cases were continued again in the U.S. Circuit Court in Covington, Ky. 

Hubbard Helm passed away September 15, 1885, when he fell from a wagon in Cincinnati. He was buried in Evergreen Cemetery in the same county where he had experienced so much in his 63 years.

I'll soon discuss Robert Maddox, the man arrested alongside Hubbard in late 1861, in an upcoming post, but I just found some new information about him that I need to review and perhaps add.

Monday, October 19, 2026

The 1861 Arrests of Hubbard Helm and Robert Maddox

In late 1861, around the time the Kentucky legislature declared its official support for the Union cause, some Federal officials began to question that commitment, fearing that the Confederacy was going to seize control of the state, and that state residents were traveling to other states to join the southern army. This was a potentially serious issue, and they had to address it.

According to historian Stuart Sanders, “to save Kentucky and to consolidate their power, by late September Union authorities began arresting prominent pro-Confederate civilians and spiriting them to out-of-state prisons without warning, formal charges, or trial.”

 Some of these men had even advised President Abraham Lincoln that “drastic measures” were needed to keep Kentucky in the Union.

This environment of paranoia and worry naturally swept through Campbell County as well, with its own local twists and turns. 

The cases of two county residents exemplify this situation late in the war's first year.

——

On September 28, 1861, the Cincinnati Daily Enquirer reported the arrests of Campbell County resident Robert Maddox and former county sheriff Hubbard Helm two days earlier. After making the arrests, Union officials took the men across the Ohio River to Cincinnati to await further orders from General Ormsby Mitchel.   

The arrest had occurred between 11:00 and midnight of the previous day when a U.S. Deputy Marshal crossed the Ohio River from Cincinnati and apprehended the duo before taking them to a Cincinnati hotel. Two companies of Home Guards assisted in the apprehension, similar to what Sanders had described.

The newspaper added that the military had two other warrants but could not find their targets, politician Thomas L. Jones and lawyer and future Confederate soldier Albert S. Berry.

The arrests were due to suspicion that Maddox and Helm “had secretly been aiding and abetting the rebels in the Confederate army.” They were under the watch of a strong guard at the hotel where authorities temporarily kept them. 

On the afternoon of the 27th, a court issued a writ of habeas corpus ordering the arresting officer to bring the detainees before a judge to explain the reasons for their confinement. Soldiers guarded them closely as they entered the court. The judge then gave the arresting office until 10:00 the next morning to provide a written explanation of his actions.

On September 30, the court ( of the Southern District of Ohio)  held a hearing. Sergeant William Pickham had the duo in his custody, but a decision did not arrive until six weeks had passed when, on November 11, a judge found: "The arrest was by the civil officers, not by the military; that the arrest was made unlawfully; but as some evidence appears that disloyalty was shown by the prisoners,” he declared that had there been a crime, it had occurred in Kentucky, out of his court’s jurisdiction, so he ordered the prisoners removed from military arrest and placed in custody of the U.S. Marshal in Kentucky.

Following a recent mandate from Congress, the judge required the pair to pay a bond of $2,000 each to ensure their faithfulness to the Union and the Constitution. 

The men soon appeared in court and completed the required paperwork, and the judge ordered the Marshal to take them to the Kentucky authorities, which he did on November 13.   

When they arrived in that office, they had to wait for the deputy marshal to return, but when he did, he was not anxious to handle this business, so another officer took charge, having noticed that "a knot of men, whose fealty to the Union" was questionable at best had gathered nearby, He then went to the Newport Barracks where he assembled a "sergeant's file of soldiers," whom he ordered to re-arrest Maddox and Helm and move them to the Barracks. 

This second apprehension angered Maddox, who “instantly sprung to his feet, and drawing a huge bowie-knife, swore he would not be taken” Soldiers approached, prepared to use force, if necessary, but as Maddox observed the gleam of their bayonets and the foreboding business ends of their long guns, he regained his composure.   

The marshal again started to escort him to the river, but Maddox had another change of heart. After only a short distance, the prisoner “swore he would rather die” than go with his guards. He turned around and tried to enter a nearby building for shelter.

This commotion could not help but draw attention. “At least five hundred” curious onlookers had gathered nearby, with more than a few hands reaching inside breast pockets as if they were preparing to grab a gun. The tension was growing.

The officer ordered the soldiers to re-apprehend Maddox, preferably without injury. The unwilling client still gripped his knife firmly and wielded it threateningly. Soldiers tried to knock it from his grasp, but he resisted, fighting for his liberty. After a brief scuffle, the soldiers loosened his hold on the gun and took it from him, enabling them to place him back under arrest.  

The captors failed in one regard. During the melee, Maddox "sustained a bayonet thrust near the right temple, which bled profusely." The soldiers then escorted him south of the river. 

Helm offered no resistance to his arrest.

Two or three weeks before this, Mitchel had issued orders to arrest the duo as soon as they were released from their initial detention. 

The Cincinnati Daily Gazette felt this latest apprehension clarified the previous court ruling: "We think there can be no doubt in the mind of Judge Leavitt 'or any other man' that 'this is a military arrest.'" 

By November 21, Maddox was still "carefully guarded but sees his friends almost every day."

Five days later, the same journal reported that two officials traveled to Louisville, where they were able to get an order from General Don Carlos Buell transferring the prisoners to that locale.

At the time, Helm was free from confinement on a parole of honor, while Maddox was still in prison in the City Barracks in Cincinnati. The two managed to get a writ of habeas corpus from a judge, but military leaders felt Buell's order took precedence. They sent Maddox to Louisville on a mailboat. Helm finished some personal business and was escorted to that city on the evening train.

On November 26, Helm and Maddox appeared before a judge in Louisville and, "there being no charges against them,” they were released. They arrived back home on November 27.

Thus ended the adventures of Robert Maddox, Hubbard Helm, and their trouble with Union authorities.

Well, at least until 1862. 

I'll examine their experiences in that year soon. 

——

Information in this post came from:
  •  Cincinnati Daily Enquirer of September 28, October 1, 1861, November 12 and 28, 1861
  • Cincinnati Daily Gazette November 14, 1861
  • Cincinnati Daily Press November 21 and 26, 1861 
  • Anatomy of a Duel: Secession, Civil War, and the Evolution of Kentucky Violence. Sanders, Stuart.  2023 University Press of Kentucky pp.32-34

Friday, September 25, 2026

An Evolution on Abolition: The Growth of George P. Webster

Some people continue to grow throughout their lives, even in adulthood, including in attitudes and perspectives. Such change is often so subtle that it goes unnoticed, but for some public figures, it is very visible.

One such example in the Civil War era is that of George Parmelee Webster. (Not the Colonel George P. Webster who died at Perryville.)

Webster, a Connecticut native, was a 49er, a lawyer, and, as secession arrived, a prominent Union supporter in Campbell County, Kentucky, making speeches and attending Union meetings throughout the area. He soon won a spot in the Kentucky legislature but resigned it to accept a position as an assistant quartermaster of U.S. Volunteers, for which he was stationed in nearby Covington, giving him opportunity to deliver other local addresses on occasion. This variety of experiences took part in the first half of his life, establishing his pattern of movement and a willingness to try something new that he kept for the rest of his years. His whole story is one of my favorites but is much too long to share here. One piece of his story, however, intrigues me - how his views of a controversial issue of the time changed during the war.

Newspaper stories describe a scuffle involving him in Newport on November 9, 1856, which, not coincidentally, was Election Day.

Webster had previously been a member of the Know-Nothing Party, but by the time of this election had become a Democrat, a change that did not sit well with his former colleagues.

As he went to vote, some nearby Know-Nothings yelled slurs at him, calling him various names. He feared for his safety and tried to back away, but someone struck him from behind while another rioter fired gunshots, though missing everyone. More insults and threats then came his way. Tension was high.

At one point, one of his antagonists loudly cheered for Republican Presidential candidate John C. Fremont in Webster’s direction. He intended it as a joke, but Webster (a supporter of Stephen A. Douglas) was in no laughing mood, responding: “That’s right. G_d D__n you; hallo for the man you like best. You are all d____d Abolitionists, and if you were in Ohio you would vote for Fremont!”

This mess eventually calmed down with no injuries (or even arrests) occurring other than perhaps some hurt feelings. Webster’s role in this fracas showed his opinion of abolitionists at that time.

After the Civil War had raged for half a year, Webster, a fervent pro-Union man and a frequent speaker at public meetings since the dawn of the secession crisis, spoke again at a gathering in Newport on October 6, 1861.

Abolition was a part of this discussion, but this time, instead of using that word as a slur against its supporters, he simply, “denied that the present war is waged for the extermination of slavery, but for the maintenance of the Union and the Constitution.”

This was not a radical change but actually showed that Webster now held a view similar to President Abraham Lincoln’s administration. That he spoke civilly on this subject on this occasion demonstrates a change in his approach since 1856. Had he used this opportunity to condemn abolitionists, as in 1856, the newspaper would have noted that, but it made no such critique.

In the next two-and-a-half years, he made his larger shift on this topic. On February 8, 1864, he appeared at an abolition meeting in Newport, at which he and another speaker, local abolitionist and lawyer Ira Root, “made strong anti-slavery speeches.” Both men were “in favor of the enlistment of negro soldiers in Kentucky.” 

Abolition was still not a popular idea in the slave state of Kentucky, but the use of African American troops was at least equally as controversial if not more so. Making such remarks in a public setting showed moral courage on Webster’s part and signaled how his attitude toward abolition had evolved drastically in the past eight years.

Following the war, he moved to St. Louis briefly, then headed to New York, where he later won a spot in that state’s legislature. At some time, maybe even before the war ended, he officially became a Republican, but just before 1890, he reverted back to being a Democrat and joined the infamous Tammany Hall organization.

He never achieved fame nor glory during his busy life, but he never stopped looking for new ventures to attempt and vocations to pursue. His life was among the most interesting stories of Campbell County in the Civil War that I've uncovered, but the growth he showed in regard to his perspective on abolition stands out as a noteworthy nugget from his life.

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

Campbell County Men of the 23rd Ky. Infantry at Pickett’s Mill

As I posted recently, I unexpectedly found information significant to my research, specifically stories about the 23rd Kentucky Infantry, in which almost 180 Campbell County men had enlisted. I learned about its role in the Battle of Pickett’s Mill, Georgia on May 27, 1864, thanks to the second part of David Powell’s Atlanta Campaign series. I also realized that Ambrose Bierce had been with William Hazen's brigade that included the 23rd Kentucky and that his essay, The Crime at Pickett's Mill, discussed action and reactions that the men of the 23rd had seen and experienced that day.

In this post, I examine Bierce's observations along with two 1890s accounts of this fight from officers in the 23rd, stories I only found by reading that book. These stories help me better understand what the Campbell County men in the regiment experienced and witnessed as they offer more battlefield specifics of the unit’s service than I have seen elsewhere. (A review of my records indicates that 64 Campbell County men remained in the unit by this point in the war. Two men were assigned to the 5th Kentucky, who was also in Hazen's brigade at the time, and one was a clerk at brigade headquarters. One was working as a division wagoner and three were on duty with the pioneer /engineering corps, while one more was in the ambulance corps. One man was serving as a regimental quartermaster. Records for others do not show definitively if the men were still with the regiment at the time, so the exact number who actually carried rifles into the fight is uncertain.  

I also came across a pair of postwar books that add context to this story.

--

On December 17, 1896, 1st Lieutenant Arnold Bradley, who had served in company C of the 23rd, published his recollections of Pickett's Mill in the National Tribune. Much of what he describes is likely similar to what the Campbell County men (a few in company C, but most in companies B, D, E, F, G, and I) saw and experienced.

On May 27, 1864, the 23rd marched towards the enemy. Bradley noted that companies in other nearby regiments used a bugler to signal to the men which way to go, his instrument creating "a perfect din of sounds.”

They marched through the woods, “over brush and logs until about 4 o’clock in the evening, when, crossing a small creek, we halted. A few scattering shots came from the front.” 

Unfortunately, this movement did not surprise the enemy, as the Rebels were “informed by our bugles the direction we had taken.” 

Along the way, Bradley found an opportunity to fill his canteen with water, a much-valued commodity: “All soldiers looked out for that necessary article before going into battle.” 

As he did so, Generals Oliver Howard and William Hazen passed closely by, speaking to each other. The nosy lieutenant eavesdropped and heard Howard tell his subordinate, “General, you will have to charge and storm the enemy’s flank, if you sacrifice your brigade.”

Being part of that brigade, Bradley was naturally alarmed by this and rushed to his fellow sergeants in the company to report the intelligence he had gathered. Their orders soon came - “Fix bayonets! Charge bayonets! Forward - Double-quick - March!”

Bierce sheds light on the mindset of these men at this moment as they headed towards combat. "It is seldom, indeed, that a subordinate officer knows anything about the disposition of the enemy’s forces—except that it is unaimable—or precisely whom he is fighting. As to the rank and file, they can know nothing more of the matter than the arms they carry. They hardly know what troops are upon their own right or left the length of a regiment away. If it is a cloudy day they are ignorant even of the points of the compass." They were simply obeying orders, marching toward whatever destiny awaited them.

In general, the author noted, "a soldier’s knowledge of what is going on about him is coterminous with his official relation to it and his personal connection with it; what is going on in front of him he does not know at all until he learns it afterward."

Bradley's report continued. “Away we went through the timber, up a hill, over a fence to an open field, down to a ravine, up another hill to another fence.”

National Tribune Dec. 17, 1896

It was a dangerous task. “Many brave comrades fell before reaching the second fence. What a shower of bullets met us! We fought each other through that fence.”

A bullet struck Bradley. Soon another slammed against his gun, rendering it inoperable, but saving his life. He did what became routine for soldiers during the war: “I picked up a dead comrade’s gun” and kept firing. 

The fight took its toll. “Our line was considerably thinned by this time.” Bradley noticed that he and his colleagues were on the extreme left of the Union line, their flank dangerously at risk of Confederate attack. He did observe other Unionists on the field, but “so far in our rear that they were no protection.”

Bradley and two others followed advice they had heard General Howard give: “Take good aim, and be sure you do good execution.” 

The 23rd Kentucky neared the enemy. The Rebels placed rocks and other obstacles in and around the fence, hoping they would provide some protection, but initially did not seem to notice the bluecoats nearing them.

They did not remain oblivious much longer. Their men were not “showing their heads any longer,” so, Bradley wrote, “we made up a squad and charged.” Here, Bradley “saw enough there to make my blood run cold; plenty of dead men, with a very lively line behind them. We hastily fired into them and hastily retreated; not before they shot the most of our squad.”

The Rebels offered their own attack: “Some of them got over the fence and were making their way under the brow of the hill we occupied, so as to gain our rear.”

Bradley now “notified Capt. Tifft (Claudius Tifft, a resident of Newport, Campbell County and the captain of company H) of our danger, he being occupied in encouraging what few men were left. He went with me to the left, and very cooly focused a pair of fieldglasses to his eyes, with which he overlooked the crawling rebels.”

"’Lower your glasses Captain; don't you see them, not 25 feet from you?’ I said.”

“Before he got the range with the glasses they fired at us. One of the balls penetrated the Captain's knee. It made him spin around on one leg, but failed to down him. The wounded man showed an unusual amount of nerve and grit. He replaced the glasses.”

"Can I help you? I asked.”

"No; go tell Lieut. Whiting to take charge of the company."

“That day ended the Captain's military campaigns. He crawled away from the enemy and made his escape. We never net again until 31 years after, when I had the pleasure of shaking his hand at Capt. Wm. Mundy's office, Louisville, Ky. I was so overcome with feeling that I was unable to speak to him for minutes. He was blind. Kind relatives had assisted him all the way from Sanborn, Iowa, to the State he once so nobly defended and represent in the struggles.”

Claudius Tifft late in life from ancestry.com

 The contest did not grow any easier. “Our ammunition supply was about exhausted.  We had already emptied our own and the dead comrades' cartridge boxes.”

A panic ensued as someone nearby yelling at others to retreat. “The command was repeated by those having authority. Most of our regimental survivors rallied around our colors in the hands of Serg's Henry. He leisurely rolled up the flag around the pole, after which we started."

(Bierce's account contradicted this version: “No command to fall back was given, none could have been heard. Man by man, the survivors withdrew at will, sifting through the trees into the cover of the ravines, among the wounded who could drag themselves back; among the skulkers whom nothing could have dragged forward.” Perhaps Bradley’s proximity to his fellow soldiers enabled him to hear something Bierce could not. Another thought is that maybe one of them misremembered such a detail.)

Bradley continued: “There were hardly enough able-bodied men left in the regiment to look after the wounded,” who were near the creek where Bradley had gathered water earlier. “Our troubles had not yet ended for that day. The enemy commenced shelling our wounded. Several shells exploded right among them.” 

The remaining soldiers quickly moved most of their injured comrades to a safer place, behind a larger hill, “more protected from the artillery.” (A handful of Campbell County soldiers were wounded on this field. Were they among those moved to safety?)

“Darkness soon after spread her black wings over the mournful sight of wounded and dying soldiers.”

From  https://civilwartalk.com/threads/picketts-mill.195452/ 

Another perspective of this fight comes from the memory of Sergeant Gregory McDermott, who published his story in the National Tribune of October 28, 1897, less than a year after Bradley’s account. Perhaps reading that one inspired him to record his own observations for posterity.

Sergeant McDermott was in the 23rd’s company I, which originally included 16 of the Campbell Countians I’m studying, at least before attrition took its toll. It appears that 8 of the county's men were still with the company, but one was under arrest at the time and another was with the engineering/pioneer corps.) 

He described how the 23rd moved forward on May 25th to connect with General Joseph Hooker’s XX Corps. They were too far behind to reach their colleagues that night, so they "camped where we were, in the mud and slush."

The next day, they continued to advance, their skirmishers leading the way. "We arrived in front of a large open field" where these veterans quickly noticed that "the Johnnies had already a strong line of earthworks." McDermott and his fellow soldiers quickly began "digging some for our own protection," finishing their own strong position by nightfall.

As they awoke the next morning, May 27th, they did not immediately see combat, and were, instead, "enjoying ourselves the best we knew how,” probably eating breakfast and perhaps reading or writing letters to or from home.

This tranquility ended soon enough. Generals William T. Sherman, Oliver O. Howard (commander of the XIV corps, including the 23rd Kentucky), David Stanley, and Thomas Wood (commander of that corps third division and the 23rd Kentucky) arrived in camp to take a peek at the enemy's works and determine how to proceed.

"It wasn't long before we were ordered to fall in." They did so and moved towards their left, but it was not easy. "The country we were passing over was wild. The underbrush was very thick. Nothing could be seen ahead. It was like groping in the darkness," a more detailed version that agreed with Bradley's.

McDermott noted one other issue that Bradley had also observed. A nearby bugler sounded his horn as a guide, but it was not necessarily a welcome one. "We objected to it on account of it attracting the Johnnies’ shells so often, for every now and then one would burst over head, breaking the branches of the trees and causing a scattering.”

They struggled through the brush, dodging enemy missiles and tramping onward for four miles before halting, at which point skirmishing began with "our boys driving straight ahead; then we moved forward in line-of-battle down through the woods.”

The intensity of the gunfire picked up, then "came a hurrah, and away we went," headed directly to their awaiting foe until coming "to a rail fence down in a hollow at the edge of a clearing of about 15 acres." After a brief pause, they climbed the fence and crossed into the clearing from where they charged "up a slight rise, into a hollow, up the hill to the top.”

The Rebels stopped behind another fence on the opposite side of the field while the attackers kept up their approach until arriving at the same barrier. Crossbars in the fence slowed the Confederate men from crossing it to attack the Yankees. McDermott and his colleagues then "drove them into the woods."

Nearby high ground provided the Confederates an effective position for their line, and they took advantage of it by "firing from that bluff at us on our left and did a great deal of damage to our front and our right."

The 23rd returned fire as long as they could but soon had used up all its ammunition and found it necessary to fall back as no help from other Union brigades had arrived and the Rebels were "giving it to us on all sides."

The regiment retreated to the other end of the field where the men assumed a prone position, but to no avail. "A lot of the boys were killed and wounded in the clearing and close to the fence.” How many Campbell County soldiers were among this group?

Sergeant McDermott then described his own wounding and the aid he received, including from a fellow member of the regiment who found him and carried him on his back until the enemy came too close and the good Samaritan had to put him down for both men’s safety.

He asserted that the men of Wood's division had been “hurled into that slaughter-pen” and that Hazen’s brigade was “almost destroyed." after Hazen had heard his division commander Wood inform Howard:

Bierce detailed a specific incident he had witnessed as the fighting wound down, this one involving the 23rd, which was on the left of Hazen's line.  "The left of our short line had fought at the corner of a cornfield, the fence along the right side of which was parallel to the direction of our retreat. As the disorganized groups fell back along this fence on the wooded side, they were attacked by a flanking force of the enemy moving through the field in a direction nearly parallel with what had been our front. This force, I infer from General Johnston’s account, consisted of the brigade of General Lowry, or two Arkansas regiments under Colonel Baucum. I had been sent by General Hazen to that point and arrived in time to witness this formidable movement. But already our retreating men, in obedience to their officers, their courage and their instinct of self-preservation, had formed along the fence and opened fire. The apparently slight advantage of the imperfect cover and the open range worked its customary miracle: the assault, a singularly spiritless one, considering the advantages it promised and that it was made by an organized and victorious force against a broken and retreating one, was checked."

Hazen reported his brigade had been “withdrawn for this attack from a position in the line where for forty-eight hours it had been very actively engaged. Many felt that this imposed on us an additional service of very great severity out of our turn. General Wood's report shows that he protested stubbornly. In a conversation with General Howard, our corps commander, when we were given the advance, he said to me that he had selected the force he thought gave the greatest promise of succeeding in the work in hand. Hazen had also heard Wood tell Howard: “We will put in Hazen and see what success he has.” (Hazen p. 256)

This proved to be a difficult and deadly fight for these soldiers, one forever ingrained in their minds, but did their superiors understand or appreciate their struggles?

Robert Kimberly, a resident of Dayton, Campbell County in the postwar years, served as a Lieutenant Colonel and brevet Brigadier General of the 41st Ohio Infantry. While living in Dayton, he co-authored a history of his regiment. Like the 23rd, the 41st had been in Hazen’s Brigade at Pickett’s Mill, though on the right side of the Union line while the 23rd was on the left. In addition to his specific comments about the 41st’s experiences he wrote: “It is a fact worth notice, that while the Confederate reports of the Atlanta campaign minutely record the Pickett's Mill battle as one of the most prominent and important events of the campaign, Gen. Sherman's memoirs wholly ignore the action.” (Kimberly p. 87)

Hazen made a similar observation in his book. This battle “is scarcely noticed in any of the reports of the Union commanders, and is ignored by Sherman in his memoirs." (Hazen p. 256)

Bierce stated it with obvious disapproval: “Buried in the official reports of the victors there are indeed imperfect accounts of the engagement: the vanquished have not thought it expedient to relate it. It is ignored by General Sherman in his memoirs, yet Sherman ordered it. General Howard wrote an account of the campaign of which it was an incident, and dismissed it in a single sentence; yet General Howard planned it, and it was fought as an isolated and independent action under his eye.”

Sherman also left this engagement out of his campaign reports, but the men remembered it well and realized how all too real it was. The hard-fought contest on overgrown, hilly ground cost the Yankees about 1,600. Perhaps Sherman or others felt that this figure was minor compared to other battles, but these losses were real to the men on the field.

Another theory is that Sherman was embarrassed by this defeat and simply denied it happened.

Hazen, however, knew and acknowledged what his men had face, calling Pickett's Mill "the most fierce, bloody and persistent assault of the Atlanta campaign." (Hazen p. 256)

According to Kimberly, “Sometime afterward, when the army had passed on toward Atlanta, several of these trenches were opened, that certain bodies might be rescued, for friends in the North. Union and Confederate were found piled together, and none could be identified.” (Kimberly p. 87)

The Campbell County men were not immune to the fates of war, of course. Two died here, while seven others were wounded and three more captured.  The two fatalities, George H. Morgan of company D  and Jerry Rose of company E, both have headstones in Marietta National Cemetery, so their remains were identified.

This fight, though relatively small and not greatly known did matter. It had “delayed Sherman’s progress; when his forces emerged from the wilderness, they were no closer to Atlanta than they had been almost two weeks earlier. The real significance of the battle was that it marked the beginning of trench warfare.”

The details on what the soldiers of the 23rd Kentucky witnessed and the challenges they faced in this battle are unlike anything else I have found; they fascinate me. 

Knowing these men fought in several deadly battles and knowing specifics of what they experienced therein are two different matters. Obviously, other contests differed from this one, but this does provide an example of their wartime adventures. It is far more than I had seen before.

---

(I must add the usual disclaimer that these (except Bierce's account) were written more than 30 years after the battle, so it is reasonable to wonder about the accuracy of all the details, but the overall stories are likely at least reasonable versions of what happened on that ground on May 27, 1864. Kimberly and/or Hazen may have still had copies of period reports that added accuracy to their writings. Perhaps Bradley and/or McDermott had kept a wartime journal.)

Books cited:

Kimbery, Robert L. and Holloway, Ephraim S. The Forty-First Ohio Veteran Volunter Infantry in the War of the Rebellion 1861 - 1865. 1897 W.R. Smellie, Printer and Publisher. Cleveland, Ohio

Hazen, William Babcock. A Narrative of Military Service 1885 Ticknor and Company, Boston

Thursday, August 27, 2026

What I Unexpectedly Learned About the 23rd Kentucky Infantry

Like what I presume virtually all Civil War students or enthusiasts do, I read about the Civil War to learn more about it and hopefully, enjoy some good writing. Sometimes, however, books take readers in unexpected directions. Such an instance for me occurred while reading volume 2 of David Powell's series on the Atlanta Campaign (see my thoughts on it here), a work that pleasantly surprised me by including details that apply to my own research, information unlike anything I had seen previously.

A few years ago, when I began my project exploring Campbell County, Kentucky in the Civil War, I started my research by identifying soldiers from the area, focusing on their individual lives and service. One of my first finds was that more than 150 of these men had enlisted in the 23rd Kentucky Infantry. I was caught off-guard to see so many names in one unit, but it was a good early discovery, a sign that I would find more information than I expected at the time.

Since then, any mention of the 23rd grabs my attention, but while I try to maintain a basic understanding of the unit’s record, I honestly spend much more effort looking into the individual soldiers than on the details of battles and military maneuvering.

The 23rd marched and fought in most of the largest fights and campaigns in the Western Theater of the war, from their reserve role in Thomas Crittenden's II Corps at Perryville, to active fighting at Stones River, Chickamauga, and the Atlanta Campaign, plus involvement with the Tullahoma Campaign, a difficult task despite the lack of bloodshed during it. As I continued to read about these fights and campaigns, I never really saw any especially memorable descriptions of their work. They fought and suffered casualties in various battles but usually came off as supporting players in most battles (though maybe I’m still missing something about another fight.)

Eventually I learned about the fight at Brown’s Ferry, Tennessee in October of 1863, where the Federals began to work to get more supplies to their troops in Chattanooga. The 23rd took a leading part in this battle, with some of its soldiers being the first men to land on the Confederate-held western bank of the Tennessee River. This lesser-known contest was a Union success, allowing the opening of what was quickly dubbed the "Cracker Line." Until now, I took that contest as being their most notable action, but some fighting on Georgia soil may change that view.

In chapter 8 of this book, Powell explores the Battle of Pickett’s Mill on May 27, 1864. I was not familiar with the details of this contest, but perhaps that lack of knowledge left me more excited when I learned that the 23rd (in William Hazen’s brigade of Thomas Woods’ division of the IV Army Corps commanded by Oliver Howard) was among the Federal units at the front of this fight. This work gives a terrific recap of this fight, painting a picture of what a tough contest it was and the many challenges the men, including in the 23rd, faced.

From battlefields.org

I started dog-earing the pages in this chapter, so now that section of my book is full of bent corners, but I don’t care. I certainly will re-read that chapter, maybe soon.

Additionally, I had never before realized that Ambrose Bierce’s The Crime at Pickett’s Mill was about the action Hazen’s men, including the 23rd, saw. I guess I had not read it since I started paying attention to the 23rd. His essay must be the most literary account of any of the 23rd’s fighting from the entire war. I have not seen any regimental history of the 23rd, or even any writings by local soldiers describing their work. Heck, even Spared & Shared appears to have nothing from the regiment, so Bierce’s essay is a nice perspective to have.

More good fortune soon fell into my lap in the shape of a pair of National Tribune stories written by members of the 23rd. (I also have an article from that newspaper about the regiment at Chickamauga, written by the same lieutenant who authored one of these reports. It is quite long, so I’ll have to re-read it.

I planned to discuss these accounts in this post, but that will take quite a bit of space, so I’ll make a separate post. Combined with Powell's work and Bierce’s account, I stumbled upon intriguing new information for my research. (And I do know that here is a book concerning this battle, a new title now on my list of future acquisitions.)

I would not have seen any of these details had I not read this book. I certainly did not expect to find information relevant to my project in a book on the Atlanta Campaign. Discoveries like this are one of the joys of reading. You never know what you might find.

Monday, August 17, 2026

A Few Thoughts on The Atlanta Campaign, Volume 2

In the study of the Civil War, reading books is still a primary way of learning more about it. Some of the many books on the subject deliver exactly what readers want, while others fall short of hopes, and a few even manage to exceed expectations.

This book exceeded what I hoped to read, as it revealed information relevant to my own research, a most pleasant surprise that certainly influences my opinion of this work.

Aside from that personal benefit (which I will discuss more in a later post), this book is just what readers have come to expect from this author. It is a detailed, heavily-researched exploration of not only the battlefield encounters, but also the maneuvering and countermoves of the opposing forces, the decision making, and the mistakes both sides made or opportunities they missed. It recounts what happened and analyzes of this stretch of the campaign. 

One feature that especially grabbed my attention is the heavier-than-usual focus on the formations that companies, regiments, brigades, and divisions employed when moving into battles. Maybe I have overlooked this in past books, but it struck me bluntly in this one, especially when Powell explained what these formations were and their suitability (or lack thereof) for the situation instead of just mentioning them. This really brought home how moving to face the enemy force was more than just heading straight towards it. It also magnified the work that officers did to start these maneuvers and attempt to keep them in order as the men approached the enemy. Terrain features such as woods, thick undergrowth, and waterways, along with man-made obstacles such as fences or felled trees, left these movements even more difficult for the soldiers to perform in the face of the enemy.

The confusion in battle as units tried to overcome these barriers and unfamiliarity with the ground to reach assigned locations or to even to know which company or regiment was next to them in the midst of this chaos comes through clearly on these pages, which even depict a diagram of the "column of division" deployment a regiment would use, right as the text describes this formation.

For those who are not experts on Civil War tactics (I raise my hand) this focus is a welcome discussion.

Powell also pays significant attention to numbers, such as the sizes of the armies and their regiments, brigades, divisions, and corps, especially right before battles. How many men were attacking or defending against how many enemies is obviously crucial information in battle studies and receives much attention on these pages.

The total casualties these units suffered during the fighting is also a frequent topic. Such data is not always easily found, especially on the Confederate side, where reports - if they even existed - were frequently lost to history. Assembling these numbers as accurately as possible was obviously a priority. Due to lack of reports or sources, the author occasionally uses his own estimates of these figures, especially battle losses, but he does provide the basis for his deductions. Analysis of such issues is strength of this book. 

This is, unsurprisingly, a stellar examination of this stretch of the fight for Atlanta, not only looking at the fights and movements, but the leaders as well. William Sherman does not come out of it looking especially good, though part of that is that the book ended at the Federals’ failed attack on Kennesaw Mountain. From his perspective, this book ended on a sour note, leaving a bad final impression.

James B. McPherson comes off as being too tentative, even when Sherman ordered him to attack and he agreed to it.

On the Confederate side, Joseph E Johnston may have missed opportunities to transition from defense to offense and exploit Federal weaknesses, and he and Rebel leaders also had problems communicating clearly and concisely, such as expressing how heavy enemy forces facing them truly were. Attacks sometimes happened or did not happen based on uncertain or incorrect information. 

This book certainly deserves a place on Civil War bookshelves and in the hands of those who enjoy studying the war. It is another high-quality work that examines its subject in great depth, a fine telling of these few weeks of this crucial campaign.

Tuesday, August 4, 2026

My 1st Confederate Ancestor: Levi Gross, 5th Ky Mounted Infantry

One topic I’ve discussed over the years on this page has involved the exploration of the lives and service of Civil War ancestors I discovered, and I even have created  a separate page  to list them and provide some basic information about them their places in my lineage.

Recently a cousin found another link to the war, but this one was different - this one was a Confederate soldier, the first of his kind in my family history.

--

Levi Gross, my first cousin five times removed, was born in 1844 in Breathitt County, Kentucky to Thomas and Sally (McIntosh) Gross, the latter of whom was my 4 times great grandaunt (the sister of my 4x great-grandfather.)

The family remained in Breathitt County - from where many of my maternal ancestors lived - in  both 1850 and 1860.

When the Civil War started in April of 1861, Levi did mot immediately enlist, perhaps due to his age, as he was under 18 years of age. Many young men found ways around this regulation, but Levi did not.

By September of 1862, he had turned 18 and on September 11 ventured to the county seat of Jackson, where he enlisted as a private in company B of the 5th Kentucky Mounted Infantry. Breathitt County, like much of Kentucky, contained divided loyalties, a two of Levi's first cousins (my 3x great grandfather Nimrod McIntosh and his brother Richard) joined U.S. units.

Levi's regiment had originally formed in the summer of 1861 as a one-year unit, though many of its men refused to re-enlist for the rest of the war. 

His wartime experience was not always happy. In October of 1862, he deserted his company at Saylersville, Kentucky, and did not return until April of 1863, when General William Preston had him restored to duty. He forfeited all pay for the time he was gone, a fairly lenient but common punishment.

As the war progressed, the 5th Kentucky eventually became part of the famous Orphan Brigade, a collection of Kentucky regiments and men who served the Confederacy but never fought in their home state. These men fought in the September 1863 contest at Chickamauga in northern Georgia, the largest and bloodiest battle in the war's Western Theater, an overwhelming Confederate triumph.

A form dated in February of 1864 reports him as being “destitute” of a pair of pants, a pair of drawers, and a blanket. A special requisition apparently resolved that issue. Levi “made his mark” on the requisition document.

His records also show that he owed $3 in April of that year due to “damage done to gun.” Unfortunately, it does not specify the type of gun it was.

Levi and his fellow orphans  then joined in the famous Atlanta Campaign through the spring and summer of 1864, a long, hard-fought series of contests that led Levi to his unfortunate destiny. (Some might contend it did the same for the Confederacy.)

As the year  progressed, the Federal and Rebel armies were still contesting Georgia soil, and on July 22,  William Hardee’s Corps of Confederates met Federals near a waterway called Intrenchment Creek  Hardee’s men attacked, but the bluecoats defeated them. 

Among the Orphan Brigade’s casualties was Levi Gross, who was injured and left on the field, where his Yankees recovered him and moved him to the hospital of the second division of their XVI Corps.

Despite this attempted care, his wound proved to be fatal and he passed away on September 14, 1864. He is buried in the Marietta Confederate Cemetery, his name engraved on a monument with 18 fellow Confederate casualties. (Not only is he my first CSA ancestor, but is also just my second ancestor to have fought and died in the war.)

His father Thomas Gross (who had married into my family tree) also served the Confederacy, joining the 5th Regiment, Kentucky Cavalry, which formed in the summer of 1862. Like his son, he became a casualty of war, though with better fortune than Levi as Union forces led by Colonel Frank Wolford’s 1st Kentucky Cavalry captured Thomas in Richmond, Ky., around July 30 or August 1, during the small engagement mentioned toward the end of this page.)

He spent time at a military prison in Louisville, then at both McLean Barracks and Kemper Barracks in Cincinnati, followed by stays at Camp Chase in Columbus, Ohio and Rock Island, Illinois, where he took the Oath of Allegiance on October 24, 1864.

 He survived his confinement and the war, but not for terribly long. He died on September 24, 1864, two years after his son succumbed to his war wounds. Thomas was buried in the Combs Cemetery in Breathitt County.